Butt Plugs

Explore our extensive butt plug collection from beginner-friendly small plugs to jewel plugs, vibrating plugs, metal and glass styles, and larger options. All butt plugs feature a flared base for safe anal use and are made from body-safe materials — shipped discreetly across the USA.

Butt plugs are designed for comfortable anal wear during solo or couples play. Shop our full range at PersonalCrave — from beginner plugs and jewel butt plugs to vibrating and metal styles.

Skip to results list
Availability
Price
to
The highest price is $198.89
Clear
400 items

Filter

Availability
Price
to
The highest price is $198.89

Butt plugs are one of the most popular anal toys for both solo and couples use. Designed to be comfortably inserted and worn, they provide a pleasurable feeling of fullness and can intensify other stimulation during play. PersonalCrave carries a comprehensive range of butt plugs for every experience level.

Our butt plug collection includes starter sets with graduated sizes, classic silicone plugs, jewel butt plugs with decorative bases in crystal and gem styles, vibrating butt plugs (including remote-controlled models), metal and glass plugs for temperature play, inflatable plugs, and larger options for experienced users.

Every butt plug in our collection has a flared base for safe anal use — the flared base prevents the toy from being fully inserted. All materials are body-safe silicone, stainless steel, or borosilicate glass. Use with plenty of water-based lubricant. Discreet US shipping with free delivery on orders over $49.

Frequently Asked Questions
What size butt plug is best for beginners?
Start with a small butt plug with an insertable width of around 0.75 to 1 inch. Many beginner-friendly plug sets include 3 graduated sizes. Using plenty of water-based lubricant and relaxing the pelvic floor muscles before insertion makes the experience comfortable.
What is a jewel butt plug?
Jewel butt plugs are anal plugs with a decorative crystal or gem at the flared base, creating an aesthetically appealing look during wear. They are typically made from stainless steel or silicone and come in a variety of gem colors.
Are metal butt plugs safe?
Yes — stainless steel and aluminum butt plugs are completely body-safe and non-porous, making them very hygienic and easy to sterilize. Metal plugs are also great for temperature play — warm in warm water for a heating sensation or cool in the fridge for a cooling effect. Never use a metal plug with extreme temperatures.
Can I wear a butt plug for extended periods?
Many people wear butt plugs for extended periods, but always listen to your body. Use a body-safe silicone plug with a comfortable flared base, use plenty of lubricant, and take breaks if you feel any discomfort. Never fall asleep wearing a butt plug.
How do I clean a butt plug?
Non-motorized silicone, metal, and glass butt plugs can be sterilized by boiling for 10 minutes or washing in a dishwasher without detergent. Motorized vibrating plugs should be cleaned with toy cleaner and warm water. Always clean thoroughly before and after use.